Experts say Edinburgh’s AI falls short despite high expectations


“Just because you’re ready does not mean you’re equipped.” Jason Adler, a Repocket Software Engineer, certainly had that in mind when he reflected on Edinburgh’s status as an AI hub. Edinburgh has been hailed as the UK’s most prepared city for AI after London—but does readiness translate into success?

Edinburgh’s AI Readiness

Edinburgh earned the title of the most AI-ready city outside London, surpassing other academic heavyweights like Oxford and Cambridge. That’s not insignificant; it implies a ready pool of talent, robust infrastructure, and a conducive policy environment. So why do some industry experts question its standing?

Consider these points:

  1. Although Edinburgh boasts of a high number of software companies and impressive digital tech sector growth, it doesn’t equal London’s tech ecosystem’s breadth and depth.
  2. Edinburgh’s smaller population base may limit the pool of skills and talent. With its size, London attracts more global talents and influential tech firms.
  3. While Edinburgh’s universities focus on AI, so do many others across the UK. Prominent AI research is not exclusive to Edinburgh.

Jon Neale, who heads UK research at JLL, pointed out that cities across the UK, excluding London, are becoming more attractive to skilled workers. He highlighted the significant economic growth in cities like Edinburgh, Manchester, and Birmingham, backed by employment data. However, Neale emphasized the need for greater infrastructure investment and research and development (R&D) to elevate these cities into top-notch innovation hubs capable of rivaling leading European hubs like Munich or Amsterdam.

The Limitations of a Readiness Tag

“Being ready doesn’t necessarily mean you will win the game,” says Jason Adler, “Sometimes, it’s not about having the best-trained team or the best facilities, but about having the right mix and knowing how to use them.”

Edinburgh’s focus on AI readiness might become its pitfall:

  • By focusing on readiness, cities like Edinburgh might overlook other critical factors such as commercialization and integration of innovations, policy adaptability to rapid changes in AI, or the ability to attract global AI investment.
  • Cities that lag in readiness indices are not necessarily weak in AI. Oxford and Cambridge may have scored lower because of their smaller population or fewer tech startups, but they have a strong track record in producing world-class AI research and spin-outs.

Moving Beyond the Hype

Edinburgh’s readiness tag has merits, but hype must be tempered with a reality check. While the city should be credited for preparing itself for the AI era, it shouldn’t rest on its laurels; readiness is the first step toward success.

Actionable advice to ensure continuous growth includes:

  • Attract more investment in AI to stimulate the growth of startups.
  • Bolster talent development, not just in AI technology but also in the fields that support its application.
  • Enhance partnerships between universities and industries to ensure a smooth transition from academia to commercialization.

As Adler pointedly reminds us, “Readiness is good. Converting readiness into tangible outcomes—that’s the mark of the champion.”

The Latest Stories

Adaptive Process Solutions delivers step change results for oil and gas produced water production
Funding falls back from record high in 2022/23, but still better than the wider venture market
Edinburgh Fintech relaunches synthetic data platform amid surging demand
Electric vehicle chargers across Highlands used as little as six times per year